900 KAR 6:050. Certificate of Need administrative regulation.

 

      RELATES TO: KRS 216B.010-216B.130, 216B.330-216B.339, 216B.455, 216B.990

      STATUTORY AUTHORITY: KRS 194A.030, 194A.050, 216B.040(2)(a)1, 216B.330

      NECESSITY, FUNCTION, AND CONFORMITY: KRS 216B.040(2)(a)1 requires the Cabinet for Health and Family Services to administer Kentucky's Certificate of Need Program and to promulgate administrative regulations as necessary for the program. This administrative regulation establishes the requirements necessary for the orderly administration of the Certificate of Need Program.

 

      Section 1. Definitions. (1) "Administrative escalation" means an approval from the cabinet to increase the capital expenditure authorized on a previously issued certificate of need.

      (2) "Cabinet" means the Cabinet for Health and Family Services.

      (3) "Certificate of Need Newsletter" means the monthly newsletter that is published by the cabinet regarding certificate of need matters and is available on the Certificate of Need Web site at http://chfs.ky.gov/ohp/con.

      (4) "Days" means calendar days, unless otherwise specified.

      (5) "Emergency circumstances" means situations that pose an imminent threat to the life, health, or safety of a citizen of the Commonwealth.

      (6) "Formal review" means the review of applications for certificate of need which are reviewed within ninety (90) days from the commencement of the review as provided by KRS 216B.062(1) and which are reviewed for compliance with the review criteria set forth at KRS 216B.040 and Section 6 of this administrative regulation.

      (7) "Improvement" means change or addition to the premises of an existing facility that enhances its ability to deliver the services that it is authorized to offer under its existing license or an approved certificate of need.

      (8) "Industrial ambulance service" means a Class I specialized provider licensed by the cabinet to serve the employees, customers, or patrons of a business, race track, recreational facility or similar organization excluding a health care facility.

      (9) "Long-term care beds" means nursing home beds, intermediate care beds, skilled nursing beds, nursing facility beds, and Alzheimer nursing home beds.

      (10) "Nonsubstantive review" is defined by KRS 216B.015(17).

      (11) "Office of Inspector General" means the office within the Cabinet for Health and Family Services that is responsible for licensing and regulatory functions of health facilities and services.

      (12) "Office or clinic" means the physical location at which health care services are provided.

      (13) "Owner" means a person as defined in KRS 216B.015(21) who is applying for the certificate of need and will become the licensee of the proposed health service or facility.

      (14) "Practice" means the individual, entity, or group that proposes to provide health care services and shall include the owners and operators of an office or clinic.

      (15) "Primarily" means a simple majority or something that occurs at least fifty-one (51) percent of the time.

      (16) "Proposed service area" means the geographic area the applicant proposes to serve.

      (17) "Public information channels" means the Division of Communications in the Cabinet for Health and Family Services.

      (18) "Public notice" means notice given through:

      (a) Public information channels; or

      (b) The cabinet's Certificate of Need Newsletter.

      (19) "Qualified academic medical center" means:

      (a) An institution of higher education which operates an accredited medical school within the Commonwealth of Kentucky;

      (b) An institution, organization, or other entity which directly or indirectly owns or is under common control or ownership with an accredited medical school operated within the Commonwealth of Kentucky; or

      (c) An individual, organization, entity, or other person which is qualified under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3)) as a result of supporting or operating in support of an institution, organization, entity, or other person of a type or types referenced in paragraphs (a) or (b) of this subsection.

      (20) "Secretary" means the Secretary of the Cabinet for Health and Family Services.

      (21) "Show cause hearing" means a hearing during which it is determined whether a person or entity has violated provisions of KRS Chapter 216B.

 

      Section 2. Letter of Intent. (1) The Certificate of Need Letter of Intent (Form #1) shall be filed with the cabinet by all applicants for a certificate of need. This shall:

      (a) Include those applicants requesting nonsubstantive review under the provisions of Section 8 of this administrative regulation; and

      (b) Not include those applicants requesting nonsubstantive review under the provisions of KRS 216B.095(3)(a) through (e).

      (2) Upon receipt of a letter of intent, the cabinet shall provide the sender with written acknowledgment of receipt of the letter and shall publish notice of the receipt in the next published certificate of need newsletter.

      (3) An application for a certificate of need shall not be processed until the letter of intent has been on file with the cabinet for thirty (30) days.

 

      Section 3. Certificate of Need Application. (1) An applicant for a certificate of need shall file an application with the cabinet on the appropriate Certificate of Need Application (forms 2A, 2B or 2C).

      (2) When filing an application for certificate of need, the applicant shall file an original and one (1) copy of the appropriate certificate of need application, together with the prescribed fee set forth in 900 KAR 6:020 with the cabinet on or before the deadlines established by Section 4 of this administrative regulation.

      (3) Formal or nonsubstantive review of an application for a certificate of need shall not begin until the application has been deemed complete by the cabinet.

      (4) The cabinet shall not deem an application complete unless:

      (a) The applicant has provided the cabinet with all of the information necessary to complete the application; or

      (b) The applicant has declined to submit the requested information and has requested that its application be reviewed as submitted.

      (5) Once an application has been declared complete, the applicant shall not submit additional information regarding the application unless the information is introduced at a public hearing.

      (6) Once an application has been declared complete, it shall not be amended to:

      (a) Increase the scope of the project;

      (b) Increase the amount of the capital expenditure;

      (c) Expand the size of the proposed service area;

      (d) Change the location of the health facility or health service; or

      (e) Change the owner, unless the application involves a licensed health facility and a change of ownership with appropriate notice has occurred after the application was submitted.

      (7) An application that has been declared complete may be amended at a public hearing to:

      (a) Decrease the scope of the project;

      (b) Decrease the amount of the capital expenditure; or

      (c) Decrease the proposed service area.

      (8) Applicants who have had proposals for certificates of need approved under the nonsubstantive review provisions of Section 8 of this administrative regulation may request the cabinet to change the specific location to be designated on the certificate of need if:

      (a) The facility has not yet been licensed;

      (b)The location is within the county listed on the certificate of need application; and

      (c) The applicant files a written request with the cabinet within 180 days of the date of issuance of the certificate of need. A request shall include the reason why the change is necessary.

      (9) If an application is not filed with the cabinet within one (1) year of the date of the filing of a letter of intent, the letter of intent shall expire, and the applicant shall file a new letter of intent at least thirty (30) days prior to submitting an application.

      (10) If an application is withdrawn, the applicant shall file a new letter of intent at least thirty (30) days prior to resubmitting an application.

      (11) An application that is not declared complete within one (1) year from the date that it is filed shall expire and shall not be placed on public notice or reviewed for approval.

 

      Section 4. Timetable for Submission of Applications. (1) The cabinet's timetable for giving public notice for applications deemed complete for formal review and for applications granted nonsubstantive review status pursuant to KRS 216B.095(3)(f) and Section 8 of this administrative regulation shall be as follows:

      (a) Public notice for organ transplantation, magnetic resonance imaging, megavoltage radiation equipment, cardiac catheterization, open heart surgery, positron emission tomography equipment and new technological developments shall be given on the third Thursday of the following months:

      1. January; and

      2. July.

      (b) Public notice for residential hospice facilities, hospice agencies and home health agencies shall be given on the third Thursday of the following months:

      1. February; and

      2. August.

      (c) Public notice for ground ambulance providers, private duty nursing services, mobile services and rehabilitation agencies shall be given on the third Thursday of the following months:

      1. March; and

      2. September.

      (d) Public notice for day health care programs, prescribed pediatric extended care facilities and personal care beds shall be given on the third Thursday of the following months:

      1. April; and

      2. October.

      (e) Public notice for long term care beds, acute care hospitals including all other State Health Plan covered services to be provided within the proposed acute care hospital, acute care hospital beds, psychiatric hospital beds, special care neonatal beds, comprehensive physical rehabilitation beds, chemical dependency beds, ambulatory care centers, freestanding ambulatory surgical centers, outpatient health care centers, and birthing centers shall be given on the third Thursday of the following months:

      1. May; and

      2. November.

      (f) Public notice for intermediate care beds for mental retardation and developmentally disabled facilities and psychiatric residential treatment facilities (PRTF) shall be given on the third Thursday of the following months:

      1. June; and

      2. December.

      (g) A proposal not included in paragraphs (a) through (f) of this subsection shall be placed in the cycle that the cabinet determines to be most appropriate.

      (2) In order to have an application deemed complete and placed on public notice, an application shall be filed with the cabinet at least fifty (50) days prior to the date of the desired public notice.

 

      Section 5. Certificate of Need Review. (1) Prior to being reviewed for the approval or denial of a certificate of need, all applications for certificate of need shall be reviewed for completeness pursuant to Section 6 of this administrative regulation.

      (2) Unless granted nonsubstantive review status, an application for a certificate of need shall be reviewed for approval or denial of the certificate of need according to the formal review criteria set forth at Section 7 of this administrative regulation.

      (3) If granted nonsubstantive review status under Section 8 of this administrative regulation, an application for a certificate of need shall be reviewed for approval or denial of the certificate of need according to the nonsubstantive review criteria set forth at Section 8 of this administrative regulation.

 

      Section 6. Completeness Review. (1) Fifteen (15) days after the deadline for filing an application in the next appropriate batching cycle, the cabinet shall conduct an initial completeness review to determine whether the application is complete for applications for both formal review and nonsubstantive review requested pursuant to Section 8 of this administrative regulation. Applications for which nonsubstantive review status has been requested pursuant to KRS 216B.095(3)(a) through (e) shall be reviewed within fifteen (15) days of receipt.

      (2) If the cabinet finds that the application for formal review is complete, the cabinet shall:

      (a) Notify the applicant in writing that the application has been deemed complete and that review of the application for the approval or denial of a certificate of need shall begin upon public notice being given; and

      (b) Give public notice in the next appropriate certificate of need newsletter that review of the application for approval or denial of a certificate of need has begun.

      (3) If the cabinet finds that the application for nonsubstantive review is complete, the cabinet shall notify the applicant in writing that the application has been deemed complete and that review of the application for the approval or denial of a certificate of need shall begin upon public notice being given.

      (4) A decision to grant or deny nonsubstantive review status shall be made within ten (10) days of the date the applicant is notified that the application has been deemed complete.

      (5) The cabinet shall give public notice for applications granted nonsubstantive review status under Section 8 of this administrative regulation in the next appropriate certificate of need newsletter that status has been granted and that review of the application for approval or denial of a certificate of need has begun. Public notice for applications granted nonsubstantive review status according to KRS 216B.095(3)(a) through (e) shall be mailed to affected persons.

      (6) A determination that an application is complete shall:

      (a) Indicate that the applicant has minimally responded to the necessary items on the application;

      (b) Not be determinative of the accuracy of, or weight to be given to, the information contained in the application; and

      (c) Not imply that the application has met the review criteria for approval of a certificate of need.

      (7) If the cabinet finds that the application is incomplete, the cabinet shall:

      (a) Provide the applicant with written notice of the information necessary to complete the application; and

      (b) Notify the applicant that the cabinet shall not deem the application complete unless within fifteen (15) days of the date of the cabinet's request for additional information:

      1. The applicant submits the information necessary to complete the application by the date specified in the request; or

      2. The applicant requests in writing that the cabinet review its application as submitted.

      (8) If, upon the receipt of the additional information requested, the cabinet finds that the application for formal review is complete, the cabinet shall:

      (a) Notify the applicant in writing that:

      1. The application for formal review has been deemed complete; and

      2. Review of the application for the approval or denial of a certificate of need shall begin upon public notice being given; and

      (b) Give public notice in the next appropriate certificate of need newsletter that review of the application for approval or denial of a certificate of need has begun.

      (9) If, upon the receipt of the additional information requested, the cabinet finds that an application for nonsubstantive review is complete, the cabinet shall:

      (a) Notify the applicant in writing that:

      1. The application has been deemed complete;

      2. Review of the application for the approval or denial of a certificate of need shall begin upon public notice being given; and

      3. A decision to grant or deny nonsubstantive review status shall be made within ten (10) days of the date that the application was deemed complete; and

      (b) Give public notice in the next appropriate certificate of need newsletter for applications granted nonsubstantive review status under Section 8 of this administrative regulation, that status has been granted and that review of the application for approval or denial of a certificate of need has begun. Public notice for applications granted nonsubstantive review status according to KRS 216B.095(3)(a) through (e) shall be mailed to affected persons.

      (10) If the application is incomplete, or if the information submitted is insufficient to complete the application, the cabinet shall:

      (a) Request the information necessary to complete the application; and

      (b) Inform the applicant that the application shall not be deemed complete and shall not be placed on public notice until:

      1. The applicant submits the information necessary to complete the application; or

      2. The applicant requests in writing that its application be reviewed as submitted.

      (11) Once an application has been deemed complete, an applicant shall not submit additional information to be made part of the public record unless:

      (a) The information is introduced at a hearing; or

      (b) In the case of a deferred application, the additional information is submitted at least twenty (20) days prior to the date that the deferred application is placed on public notice.

      (12) A determination that an application is complete shall:

      (a) Indicate that the application is sufficiently complete to be reviewed for approval or disapproval;

      (b) Not be determinative of the accuracy of, or weight to be given to, the information contained in the application; and

      (c) Not imply that the application has met the review criteria for approval.

 

      Section 7. Considerations for Formal Review. In determining whether to approve or deny a certificate of need, the cabinet's review of applications under formal review shall be limited to the following considerations:

      (1) Consistency with plans.

      (a) To be approved, a proposal shall be consistent with the State Health Plan established in 900 KAR 5:020.

      (b) In determining whether an application is consistent with the State Health Plan, the cabinet shall apply the latest inventories and need analysis figures maintained by the cabinet and the version of the State Health Plan in effect at the time of the cabinet's decision.

      (c) An application seeking to reestablish a licensed healthcare, facility, or service, which was provided at the healthcare facility and which was voluntarily discontinued by the applicant, shall be considered consistent with the State Health Plan under the following circumstances:

      1. The termination or voluntary closure of the former healthcare service or facility:

      a. Was not the result of an order or directive by the cabinet, governmental agency, judicial body, or other regulatory authority;

      b. Did not occur during or after an investigation by the cabinet, governmental agency, or other regulatory authority;

      c. Did occur while the facility was in substantial compliance with applicable administrative regulations and was otherwise eligible for relicensure;

      d. Was not an express condition of any subsequent Certificate of Need approval; and

      e. Did not occur less than twenty-four (24) months prior to the submission of the application to reestablish;

      2. The proposed healthcare service shall be provided within the same service area as the former healthcare service;

      3. The proposed healthcare facility shall be located within the same county as the former healthcare facility and at a single location; and

      4. The application shall not seek to reestablish any type of bed utilized in the care and treatment of patients for more than twenty-three (23) consecutive hours.

      (2) Need. The cabinet shall determine:

      (a) If the applicant has identified a need for the proposal in the geographic area defined in the application; and

      (b) If the applicant has demonstrated that it is able to meet the need identified in the geographic area defined in the application.

      (3) Accessibility. The cabinet shall determine if the health facility or health service proposed in the application will be accessible in terms of timeliness, amount, duration, and personnel sufficient to provide the services proposed.

      (4) Interrelationships and linkages. The cabinet shall determine:

      (a) If the proposal shall serve to accomplish appropriate and effective linkages with other services, facilities, and elements of the health care system in the region and state; and

      (b) If the proposal is accompanied by assurance of effort to achieve comprehensive care, proper utilization of services, and efficient functioning of the health care system.

      (5) Costs, economic feasibility, and resource availability. The cabinet shall determine:

      (a) If it is economically feasible for the applicant to implement and operate the proposal; and

      (b) If applicable, if the cost of alternative ways of meeting the need identified in the geographic area defined in the application would be a more effective and economical use of resources.

      (6) Quality of services. The cabinet shall determine:

      (a) If the applicant is prepared to and capable of undertaking and carrying out the responsibilities involved in the proposal in a manner consistent with appropriate standards and requirements established by the cabinet; and

      (b) Whether the applicant has the ability to comply with applicable licensure requirements. The fact that there is not an applicable licensure category shall not constitute grounds for disapproving an application.

 

      Section 8. Nonsubstantive Review. (1) The cabinet may grant nonsubstantive review status to applications to change the location of a proposed health facility or to relocate a licensed health facility only if:

      (a)1. There is no substantial change in health services or bed capacity; and

      2. The change of location or relocation is within the same county; or

      (b) The change of location for a psychiatric residential treatment facility is within the same district as defined in KRS 216B.455 and is to the same campus as a licensed psychiatric residential treatment facility.

      (2) In addition to the projects specified in KRS 216B.095(3)(a) through (e) pursuant to KRS 216B.095(f), the Division of Certificate of Need may grant nonsubstantive review status to an application for which a certificate of need is required if:

      (a) The proposal involves the establishment or expansion of a health facility or health service for which there is not a component in the State Health Plan;

      (b) The proposal involves an application from a hospital to reestablish the number of acute care beds that it converted to nursing facility beds pursuant to KRS 216B.020(4), if the number of nursing facility beds so converted are delicensed;

      (c) The proposal involves an application to relocate nursing facility beds from one long term care facility to another long term care facility and the requirements established in this paragraph are met.

      1. If the relocation takes place within the same county, the following restrictions shall apply:

      a. The application shall be filed on or before October 1, 2008; and

      b. The application shall be accompanied by a properly completed notice of intent to acquire (form #9), and by evidence of the selling or transferring facility’s binding commitment to sell or transfer upon approval of the application.

      2. If the relocation is to be from one county to another county, the following restrictions shall apply:

      a. The letter of intent shall be filed no later than September 1, 2008 and the application shall be filed no later than October 1, 2008;

      b. The application shall be accompanied by a properly completed notice of intent to acquire (form #9), and by evidence of the selling or transferring facility’s binding commitment to sell or transfer upon approval of the application;

      c. The selling or transferring facility shall be located in a county that had a nursing facility bed occupancy rate of less than ninety-five (95) percent (rounded up to the next whole number if ninety-four and five-tenths (94.5) percent or greater and rounded down to the next whole number if less than ninety-four and five-tenths (94.5) percent) according to the latest published version of the Kentucky Annual Long Term Care Services Report;

      d. The acquired beds shall only be relocated to a county whose nursing facility bed occupancy was ninety-five (95) percent or greater (rounded up to the next whole number if ninety-four and five-tenths (94.5) percent or greater and rounded down to the next whole number if less than ninety-four and five-tenths (94.5) percent) according to the latest published version of the Kentucky Annual Long Term Care Services Report;

      e. A long term care facility shall not sell, transfer, or acquire more than fifteen (15) of its licensed nursing facility beds; and

      f. Notwithstanding the occupancy rates provided in clauses c and d in this subparagraph, the cabinet may grant nonsubstantive review status to an application to transfer licensed nursing facility beds between facilities that have common ownership or management.

      (d)

      .

      1. The proposal involves an application to relocate or transfer licensed acute care beds, not including neonatal Level III beds, from one (1) existing licensed hospital to another existing licensed hospital within the same area development district; and

      a. There is no increase in the total number of licensed acute care beds in that area development district; and

      b. The hospital from which the beds are relocated delicenses those beds; and

      2. If neonatal Level II beds are relocated or transferred pursuant to this subsection:

      a. The receiving hospital shall have an existing licensed Level II or Level III neonatal unit;

      b. A minimum of four (4) beds shall be relocated; and

      c. The relocation shall not leave the transferring hospital with less than four (4) neonatal Level II beds unless the relocated beds represent all of its neonatal Level II beds;

      (e) The proposal involves an application by an existing licensed hospital to:

      1. Convert licensed psychiatric or chemical dependency beds to acute care beds, not including special purpose acute care beds such as neonatal Level II beds or neonatal Level III beds;

      2. Convert and implement the beds on-site at the hospital’s existing licensed facility; and

      3. Delicense the same number of psychiatric or chemical dependency beds that are converted; or

      (f) The proposal involves an application by an existing licensed hospital providing inpatient psychiatric treatment to:

      1. Convert psychiatric beds licensed for use with geriatric patients to acute care beds, not including special purpose acute care beds such as neonatal Level II beds or neonatal Level III beds;

      2. Implement the beds on-site at the existing licensed hospital; and

      3. Delicense the same number of converted beds.

      (3) If an application is denied nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need, the application shall automatically be placed in the formal review process.

      (4) If an application is granted nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need, notice of the decision to grant nonsubstantive review status shall be given to the applicant and all known affected persons.

      (5) If an application is granted nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need, any affected person who believes that the applicant is not entitled to nonsubstantive review status or who believes that the application should not be approved may request a hearing by filing a request for a hearing within ten (10) days of the notice of the decision to conduct nonsubstantive review. The provisions of Section 16 of this administrative regulation shall govern the conduct of all nonsubstantive review hearings. Nonsubstantive review applications shall not be comparatively reviewed but may be consolidated for hearing purposes.

      (6) If an application for certificate of need is granted nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need, there shall be a presumption that the facility or service is needed and applications granted nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need shall not be reviewed for consistency with the State Health Plan.

      (7) The cabinet shall approve applications for certificates of need that have been granted nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need if:

      (a) The application does not propose a capital expenditure; or

      (b) The application does propose a capital expenditure and the cabinet finds that the facility or service with respect to which the capital expenditure is proposed to be made is required. The cabinet shall find that the facility or service with respect to which the capital expenditure is proposed to be made is required, unless the cabinet finds that the presumption of need provided for in subsection (6) of this section has been rebutted by clear and convincing evidence by an affected party.

      (8) The cabinet shall disapprove applications for certificates of need that have been granted nonsubstantive review if:

      (a) The cabinet finds that the applicant is not entitled to nonsubstantive review status; or

      (b) The cabinet finds that the presumption of need provided for in subsection (6) of this section has been rebutted by clear and convincing evidence by an affected party.

      (9) The cabinet shall approve or disapprove an application which has been granted nonsubstantive review status by the Division of Certificate of Need within thirty-five (35) days of the date that public notice is given that nonsubstantive review status has been granted.

      (10) If a certificate of need is denied following nonsubstantive review, the applicant may:

      (a) Request that the cabinet reconsider its decision pursuant to KRS 216B.090 and Section 17 of this administrative regulation;

      (b) Request that the application be placed in the next cycle of the formal review process; or

      (c) Seek judicial review pursuant to KRS 216B.115.

 

      Section 9. Notice of Decision. (1) The cabinet shall notify the applicant and any party to the proceeding of the final action on a certificate of need application.

      (2) Notification of approval shall be in writing and shall include:

      (a) Verification that the review criteria for approval have been met;

      (b) Specification of any terms or conditions limiting a certificate of need approval, including limitations regarding certain services or patients. This specification shall be listed on the facility or service's certificate of need and license;

      (c) Notice of appeal rights; and

      (d) The amount of capital expenditure authorized, if applicable.

      (3) Written notification of disapproval shall include:

      (a) The reason for the disapproval; and

      (b) Notice of appeal rights.

      (4) An application for certificate of need that is disapproved shall not be refiled for a period of twelve (12) months from the original date of filing, absent a showing of a significant change in circumstances.

 

      Section 10. Deferral of an Application. (1) An applicant may defer review of an application by notifying the cabinet in writing of its intent to defer review.

      (a) If the application has been granted nonsubstantive review status, the notice to defer shall be filed no later than five (5) days prior to the date that the decision is due on the application unless a hearing has been scheduled. If a hearing has been scheduled, the notice to defer shall be filed no later than six (6) days prior to the date of the hearing.

      (b) If the application is being reviewed under formal review, the notice to defer shall be filed no later than ten (10) days prior to the date that the decision is due on the application unless a hearing has been scheduled. If a hearing has been scheduled, the notice to defer shall be filed eight (8) days prior to the date of the hearing.

      (c) If a hearing has been scheduled, the applicant shall also notify all parties to the proceedings in writing of the applicant's intent to defer the application.

      (2) If deferral is requested, the application shall be deferred to the next regular batching cycle and shall be placed on public notice pursuant to the timetables set forth at Section 4 of this administrative regulation.

      (3) If an application is deferred, an applicant may update its application by providing additional information to the cabinet at least twenty (20) days prior to the date that the deferred application is placed on public notice.

      (4) In order for a hearing to be held on a deferred application, a hearing shall be requested by either the applicant or an affected person within:

      (a) Ten (10) days of the deferred application being placed on public notice if the application has been granted nonsubstantive review status; or

      (b) Fifteen (15) days of the deferred application being placed on public notice if the application is being reviewed under the provision of formal review.

 

      Section 11. Withdrawal of an Application. (1) An applicant may withdraw an application for certificate of need prior to the entry of a decision to deny or approve the application by notifying the cabinet in writing of the decision to withdraw the application.

      (2) If a hearing has been scheduled or held on the application, the applicant shall also notify all parties to the proceedings in writing of the applicant's decision to withdraw the application.

 

      Section 12. Emergency Circumstances. (1) If an emergency circumstance arises, a person may proceed to alleviate the emergency without first obtaining a certificate of need if:

      (a)1. The person is not a hospital, and the person is licensed by the appropriate Kentucky licensing authority to provide the service necessary to alleviate the emergency; or

      2. The person is a hospital, and the hospital has an already- issued certificate of need to provide the service necessary to alleviate the emergency;

      (b) The Division of Certificate of Need is notified in writing within five (5) days of the commencement of the provision of the service required to alleviate the emergency; and

      (c) The Division of Certificate of Need acknowledges in writing that it recognizes that an emergency does exist.

      (2) The notice to the Division of Certificate of Need shall be accompanied by an affidavit and other documentation from the person proposing to provide emergency services, which shall contain the following information:

      (a) A detailed description of the emergency which shall include at least the following information:

      1. A description of health care services that will be provided to the person or persons to whom the services will be provided, including proof of eligibility for the service;

      2. A list of the providers in the county licensed to provide the services that will be provided during the emergency; and

      3. Proof that:

      a. Other providers licensed in the service area to provide the service are aware of the need for the service to be provided to the person and have refused or are unable to provide the service; or

      b. Circumstances exist under which the transfer of a patient to another provider licensed in the service area to provide the service would present an unacceptable risk to a patient's life, health, or safety;

      (b) The steps taken to alleviate the emergency;

      (c) The location or geographic area where the emergency service is being provided; and

      (d) The expected duration of the emergency.

      (3) The Division of Certificate of Need may request additional information necessary to make its determination from the person proposing to provide emergency services before it acknowledges that an emergency does exist.

      (4) If the provision of service to meet the emergency circumstance is required to continue beyond thirty (30) days from the date that the notice is filed with the cabinet, the person providing the emergency service shall file an application for a certificate of need for the next appropriate public notice pursuant to Section 4 of this administrative regulation.

      (5) The person providing the emergency service may continue to alleviate the emergency circumstances without a certificate of need until:

      (a) The emergency ceases to exist; or

      (b) The cabinet issues a final decision to approve or disapprove the application for certificate of need.

 

      Section 13. Transfers of Certificates of Need. (1) Certificates of need issued to an existing facility for purposes other than replacement of the facility may be transferred to the new owner of the facility if the change of ownership occurs prior to implementation of the project for which the certificate of need was issued.

      (2) The purchase of all capital stock or a controlling interest of capital stock of a person who is the holder of an approved certificate of need for the establishment of a new health facility shall not constitute the sale, trade or transfer of a certificate of need to another person for purposes of KRS 216B.061(1)(h) and 216B.0615.

 

      Section 14. Location of New and Replacement Facilities. A certificate of need approved for the establishment of a new facility or the replacement of an existing facility shall be valid only for the location stated on the certificate.

 

      Section 15. Filings. (1) The filing of all documents required by this administrative regulation shall be made by filing the documents with the Division of Certificate of Need, HS1E-D, 1st Floor, Health Services Building, 275 East Main Street, Frankfort, Kentucky 40621 on or before 4:30 p.m. eastern time on the due date.

      (2) Filings of documents, other than certificate of need applications and proposed hearing reports, may be made by facsimile transmission if:

      (a) The documents are received by the cabinet by facsimile transmission on or before 4:30 p.m. eastern time on the date due; and

      (b) An original document is filed with the cabinet on or before 4:30 p.m. eastern time on the next business day after the due date.

      (3) Failure to file documents in accordance with the schedule and manner provided in subsections (1) and (2) of this section shall result in the materials being returned to the sender and the cabinet shall not take additional action until the material is properly resubmitted.

      (4) The Division of Certificate of Need shall endorse by file stamp the date that each filing is received and the endorsement shall constitute the filing of the document.

      (5) In computing any period of time prescribed by this administrative regulation, the date of notice, decision or order shall not be included.

      (6) The last day of the period so computed shall be included, unless it is a Saturday, a Sunday or legal state holiday, in which event the period shall run until 4:30 p.m. eastern time of the first business day following the Saturday, Sunday, or legal state holiday.

 

      Section 16. Hearings. (1) Hearings on certificate of need matters shall be held by hearing officers from the Cabinet for Health and Family Services, Health Services Administrative Hearings Branch. A hearing officer shall not act on any matter in which the hearing officer has a conflict of interest as defined in KRS 45A.340. Any party may file with the cabinet a petition for removal based upon a conflict of interest supported by affidavit.

      (2) The hearing officer shall preside over the conduct of each hearing and shall regulate the course of the proceedings in a manner which shall promote the orderly and prompt conduct of the hearing.

      (3) Notice of the time, date, place and subject matter of each hearing shall be:

      (a) Mailed to the applicant and all known affected persons providing the same or similar service in the proposed service area not less than ten (10) days prior to the date of the hearing;

      (b) Published in the CON newsletter if applicable; and

      (c) Provided to members of the general public through public information channels.

      (4) A public hearing shall be canceled if the person or persons who requested the hearing withdraws the request by giving written notification to the Office of Certificate of Need that the hearing is no longer required. The consent of affected persons who have not requested a hearing shall not be required in order for a hearing to be canceled.

      (5) Any dispositive motion made by a party to the proceedings shall be filed with the hearing officer at least three (3) working days prior to the scheduled date of the hearing.

      (6) The hearing officer may convene a preliminary conference.

      (a) The purposes of the conference shall be to:             1. Formulate and simplify the issues;

      2. Identify additional information and evidence needed for the hearing; and

      3. Dispose of pending motions.

      (b) A written summary of the preliminary conference and the orders thereby issued shall be made a part of the record.

      (c) The hearing officer shall:

      1. Tape record the conference; or

      2. If requested by a party to the proceedings, arrange for a stenographer to be present at the expense of the requesting party.

      (d) During the preliminary conference, the hearing officer may:

      1. Instruct the parties to:

      a. Formulate and submit a list of genuine contested issues to be decided at the hearing;

      b. Raise and address issues that can be decided before the hearing; or

      c. Formulate and submit stipulations to facts, laws, and other matters;

      2. Prescribe the manner and extent of the participation of the parties or persons who will participate;

      3. Rule on any pending motions for discovery or subpoenas; or

      4. Schedule dates for the submission of prefiled testimony, further preliminary conferences, and submission of briefs and documents.

      (7) At least five (5) days prior to the scheduled date of any nonsubstantive review hearings and at least seven (7) days prior to the scheduled date of all other hearings, all persons wishing to participate as a party to the proceedings shall file an original and one (1) copy of the following for each affected application with the cabinet and serve copies on all other known parties to the proceedings:

      (a) Notice of Appearance, Form #3;

      (b) Witness List, Form #4; and

      (c) Exhibit List, Form #5 and attached exhibits.

      (8)(a) If a hearing is requested on an application which has been deferred from a previous cycle and for which a hearing had previously been scheduled, parties shall:

      1. File a new Notice of Appearance, Form #3; and

      2. Either:

      a. Incorporate previously-filed witness lists (Form #4) and exhibit lists (Form #5); or

      b. File amended Forms #4 and #5.

      (b) A new party to the hearings shall file original Forms #3, #4 and #5.

      (c) Forms shall be filed in accordance with subsection (7) of this section.

      (9) The hearing officer shall convene the hearing and shall state the purpose and scope of the hearing or the issues upon which evidence shall be heard. All parties appearing at the hearing shall enter an appearance by stating their names and addresses.

      (10) Each party shall have the opportunity to:

      (a) Present its case;

      (b) Make opening statements;

      (c) Call and examine witnesses;

      (d) Offer documentary evidence into the record;

      (e) Make closing statements; and

      (f) Cross-examine opposing witnesses on:

      1. Matters covered in direct examination; and

      2. At the discretion of the hearing officer, other matters relevant to the issues.

      (11) A party that is a corporation shall be represented by an attorney licensed to practice in the Commonwealth of Kentucky.

      (12) The hearing officer may:

      (a) Allow testimony or other evidence on issues not previously identified in the preliminary order which may arise during the course of the hearing, including any additional petitions for intervention which may be filed;

      (b) Act to exclude irrelevant, immaterial or unduly repetitious evidence; and

      (c) Question any party or witness.

      (13) The hearing officer shall not be bound by the Kentucky Rules of Evidence. Relevant hearsay evidence may be allowed at the discretion of the hearing officer.

      (14) The hearing officer shall have discretion to designate the order of presentation of evidence and the burden of proof as to persuasion.

      (15) Witnesses shall be examined under oath or affirmation.

      (16) Witnesses may, at the discretion of the hearing officer:

      (a) Appear through deposition or in person; and

      (b) Provide written testimony in accordance with the following:

      1. The written testimony of a witness shall be in the form of questions and answers or a narrative statement;

      2. The witness shall authenticate the document under oath; and

      3. The witness shall be subject to cross-examination.

      (17) The hearing officer may accept documentary evidence in the form of copies of excerpts if:

      (a) The original is not readily available;

      (b) Upon request, parties are given an opportunity to compare the copy with the original; and

      (c) The documents to be considered for acceptance are listed on and attached to the party's Exhibit List (Form #5) and filed with the hearing officer and other parties at least:

      1. Seven (7) working days before the hearing for formal review applications; or

      2. Five (5) working days for nonsubstantive review applications.

      (18) A document shall not be incorporated into the record by reference without the permission of the hearing officer. Any referenced document shall be precisely identified.

      (19) The hearing officer may take official notice of facts which are not in dispute, or of generally-recognized technical or scientific facts within the agency's special knowledge.

      (20) The hearing officer may permit a party to offer, or request a party to produce, additional evidence or briefs of issues as part of the record within a designated time after the conclusion of the hearing. During this period, the hearing record shall remain open. The conclusion of the hearing shall occur when the additional information is timely filed or at the end of the designated time period, whichever occurs first.

      (21) In a hearing on an application for a certificate of need, the hearing officer shall, upon the agreement of the applicant, continue a hearing beyond the review deadlines established by KRS 216B.062(1) and 216B.095(1).

      (22) The cabinet shall forward a copy of the hearing officer's final decision by U.S. mail to each party to the proceedings. The original hearing decision shall be filed in the administrative record maintained by the cabinet.

 

 

      Section 17. Requests for Reconsideration. (1) In order to be considered, requests for reconsideration shall be filed within fifteen (15) days of the date of the notice of the cabinet's final decision relating to:

      (a) Approval or disapproval of an application for a certificate of need;

      (b) An advisory opinion entered after a public hearing;

      (c) Revocation of a certificate of need; or

      (d) A show cause hearing conducted in accordance with Section 18 of this administrative regulation.

      (2) A copy of the request for reconsideration shall be served by the requester on all parties to the proceedings.

      (3) A party to the proceedings shall have seven (7) days from the date of service of the request for reconsideration to file a response to the request with the cabinet.

      (4) If a hearing was held pursuant to subsection (1)(a), (b), or (c) of this section, the hearing officer that presided over the hearing shall enter a decision to grant or deny a request for reconsideration within thirty (30) days of the request being filed.

      (5) If a hearing was held pursuant to subsection (1)(d) of this section, the secretary shall enter a decision to grant or deny a request for reconsideration within thirty (30) days of the request being filed.

      (6) If reconsideration is granted a hearing shall be held by the cabinet in accordance with the applicable provisions of Section 16 or 18 of this administrative regulation within thirty (30) days of the date of the decision to grant reconsideration and a final decision shall be entered by the cabinet no later than thirty (30) days following the conclusion of the hearing.

      (7) If reconsideration is granted on the grounds that a public hearing was not held pursuant to KRS 216B.085, the applicant shall have the right to waive the reconsideration hearing if the deficiencies in the application can be adequately corrected by submission of written documentation to be made a part of the record without a hearing.

 

      Section 18. Show Cause Hearings. (1) The cabinet may conduct a show cause hearing on its own initiative or at the request of an affected person, to include hearings requested pursuant to Humana of Kentucky v. NKC Hospitals, Ky., 751 S.W.2d 369 (1988), in order to determine if a person has established or is operating a health facility or health service in violation of the provisions of KRS Chapter 216B or this administrative regulation or is subject to the penalties provided by KRS 216B.990 for specific violations of the provisions of KRS Chapter 216B.

      (2) Unless initiated by the cabinet, in order for a show cause hearing to be held, a request for a show cause hearing submitted by an affected person shall be accompanied and corroborated by credible, relevant, and substantial evidence, including an affidavit or other documentation which demonstrates that there is probable cause to believe that a person:

      (a) Has established, or is operating, a health facility or health service in violation of the provisions of KRS Chapter 216B or this administrative regulation; or

      (b) Is subject to the penalties provided by KRS 216B.990 for specific violations of the provisions of KRS Chapter 216B.

      (3) Based upon the materials accompanying the request for a show cause hearing, the cabinet shall determine if sufficient cause exists to conduct a hearing.

      (4) The cabinet shall conduct a show cause hearing based on its own investigation pursuant to an annual licensure inspection or otherwise which reveals a possible violation of the terms or conditions which are a part of a certificate of need approval and license.

      (5) The cabinet shall also conduct a show cause hearing regarding terms and conditions which are a part of a certificate of need approval and license at the request of any person.

      (6) The show cause hearing regarding the terms and conditions shall determine whether a person is operating a health facility or health service in violation of any terms or conditions which are a part of that certificate of need approval and license.

      (7) Show cause hearings shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of Section 16 of this administrative regulation.

      (8) If a show cause hearing is held, the individual or entity alleged to be in violation of KRS Chapter 216B shall have the burden of showing that the individual or entity:

      (a) Has not established or is not operating a health facility or health service in violation of the provisions of KRS Chapter 216B or this administrative regulation; or

      (b) Is not subject to the penalties provided by KRS 216B.990 for specific violations of the provisions of KRS Chapter 216B.

      (9)(a) Except as provided by paragraph (b) or (c) of this subsection, if it is alleged that an office or clinic offering services or equipment covered by the State Health Plan was established or is operating in violation of KRS 216B.020(2)(a), the hearing officer shall base his or her findings of fact and proposed decision on whether the evidence has established the following:

      1. The practice claiming the exemption is 100 percent owned in any organizational form recognized by the Commonwealth by the individual physician, dentist, or other practitioner of the healing arts or group of physicians, dentists, or other practitioners of the healing arts (hereinafter collectively referred to as "physician") claiming the exemption;

      2. The practice claiming the exemption primarily provides physician services (e.g., evaluation and management codes) rather than services or equipment covered by the State Health Plan;

      3. Services or equipment covered by the State Health Plan which are offered or provided at the office or clinic shall be primarily provided to patients whose medical conditions are being treated or managed by the practice;

      4. A physician or physicians licensed to practice and practicing in Kentucky within the practice claiming the exemption are responsible for all decisions regarding the care and treatment provided to patients;

      5. Patients are treated on an outpatient basis and are not maintained overnight on the premises of the office or clinic;

      6. Services or equipment covered by the State Health Plan which are offered or provided at the office or clinic are related to the professional services offered to patients of the practice claiming the exemption;

      7. Major medical equipment in excess of the limits set forth in 900 KAR 6:030 is not being utilized without a Certificate of Need or other statutory or regulatory exemption; and

      8. Nothing in this section shall limit or prohibit the continued operation of an office or clinic which was established and in operation prior to January 31, 2006, and operating pursuant to and in accordance with the following:

      a. Provisions of a Certificate of Need advisory opinion issued specifically with respect to that office or clinic;

      b. Provisions of an Attorney General opinion issued specifically with respect to that office or clinic; or

      c. An order issued with respect to that office or clinic by a court of competent jurisdiction in the Commonwealth of Kentucky.

      (b) A practice owned entirely by a radiologist or group of radiologists shall demonstrate the following:

      1. Compliance with paragraph (a)1, 4, 5, and 6 of this subsection;

      2. The radiologists shall regularly perform physician services (e.g., test interpretations) at the location where the diagnostic tests are performed, including interpretations by or through teleradiology; and

      3. The billing patterns of the practice indicate that the practice is not primarily a testing facility and that it was organized to provide the professional services of radiology.

      (c) An office or clinic owned and operated by a Qualified Ac ademic Medical Center shall demonstrate the following:

      1. The physician or physicians providing care and treatment to the patients of the office or clinic shall be licensed to practice in Kentucky and shall be employed by the Qualified Academic Medical Center; and

      2.a. The office was established and in operation prior to January 31, 2006;

      b. The office does not provide any services or equipment covered by the State Health Plan; or

      c. At the time the office began providing care and treatment to patients, it was not located in a county designated as a Metropolitan Statistical Area as defined by the U.S. Office of Management and Budget, and there is a documented agreement of support or collaboration between the Qualified Academic Medical Center and each existing hospital in the county in which the office is located.

      (10) Prior to convening a show cause hearing, the cabinet shall give the person suspected or alleged to be in violation not less than twenty (20) days' notice of its intent to conduct a hearing.

      (11) The notice shall advise the person of:

      (a) The allegations against him;

      (b) Any facts determined to exist which support the existence of the allegation; and

      (c) The statute or administrative regulation alleged to have been violated.

      (12) Notice of the time, date, place, and subject matter of each hearing shall be:

      (a) Mailed to all known affected persons or entities not less than ten (10) business days prior to the date of the hearing; and

      (b) Published in the Certificate of Need newsletter if applicable.

      (13) At least seven (7) business days prior to all hearings required or requested pursuant to KRS Chapter 216B, with the exception of hearings involving applications for or revocation of a certificate of need, all persons or entities wishing to participate as a party to the proceedings shall file an original and one (1) copy of the following with the cabinet and serve copies on all other known parties to the proceedings:

      (a) Notice of Appearance, (Form #3);

      (b) Witness List, (Form #4); and

      (c) Exhibit List, (Form #5) and attached exhibits.

      (14) Within thirty (30) days of the conclusion of the hearing, the hearing officer shall tender findings of fact and a proposed decision to the secretary.

      (15) Within thirty (30) days of the receipt of the findings of fact and proposed decision from the hearing officer, the secretary shall issue a final decision on the matter.

      (16) A copy of the final decision shall be mailed to the person or his legal representative with the original hearing decision filed in the administrative record maintained by the cabinet.

      (17) If a violation is found to have occurred as a result of a show cause hearing conducted pursuant to subsection (1) of this section, the cabinet shall take action as provided by KRS Chapter 216B.

      (18) If the person is found to have violated any of the terms or conditions of any certificate of need approval and license as a result of a show cause hearing conducted pursuant to subsection (4) of this section, the cabinet shall take the following action:

      (a) If the person had not previously been found to be in violation of the terms and conditions which were made a part of the person's certificate of need approval and license, the person shall be given a reasonable period of time, not to exceed sixty (60) days after issuance of the cabinet's decision, in which to demonstrate that the violation has been corrected. At the conclusion of this period, the cabinet shall verify that the facility or service is operating in compliance with the terms or conditions of the certificate of need and license at issue.

      (b) If the cabinet is unable to verify that the facility or service has corrected the violation in accordance with paragraph (a) of this subsection, or if a person who had previously been found to be in violation of the terms and conditions which were a part of the person's certificate of need approval and license is found in a subsequent show cause hearing conducted pursuant to this section to be in violation of the terms and conditions again, the matter shall be referred to the Office of Inspector General for appropriate action.

      (19) The deadlines established with respect to hearings shall be modified, if agreed to by all parties and the hearing officer.

 

      Section 19. Administrative Escalations. (1) A person shall not obligate a capital expenditure in excess of the amount authorized by an existing certificate of need unless the person has received an administrative escalation or an additional certificate of need from the cabinet.

      (2) Requests for administrative escalations shall be submitted to the cabinet on the Cost Escalation Form, Form #6.

      (3) The cabinet shall authorize administrative escalations for funds which have not been obligated and which do not exceed the following limits if there is not a substantial change in the project:

      (a) Twenty (20) percent of the capital expenditure authorized on the original certificate of need or $100,000, whichever is greater, if the capital expenditure authorized on the certificate of need is less than $500,000;

      (b) Twenty (20) percent of the capital expenditure if the capital expenditure authorized on the certificate of need is $500,0000 to $4,999,999;

      (c) Ten (10) percent of the amount in excess of $5,000,000, plus $1,000,000, for projects if the capital expenditure authorized on the certificate of need is $5,000,000 to $24,999,999;

      (d) Five (5) percent of the amount in excess of $25,000,000, plus $3,000,000, if the capital expenditure authorized on the certificate of need is $25,000,000 to $49,999,999; and

      (e) Two (2) percent of the amount in excess of $50,000,000, plus $4,250,000, if the capital expenditure authorized on the certificate of need is $50,000,000 or more.

      (4) If an administrative escalation is authorized, the certificate of need holder shall submit any additional certificate of need application fee required by the increased capital expenditure.

      (5) The escalation of a capital expenditure in excess of the limits set forth in subsection (3) of this section shall:

      (a) Constitute a substantial change in a project; and

      (b) Require a certificate of need pursuant to KRS 216B.061(1)(e).

      (6) The unauthorized obligation of a capital expenditure in excess of the amount authorized on a certificate of need shall be:

      (a) Presumed to be a willful violation of KRS Chapter 216B; and

      (b) Subject to the penalties set forth at KRS 216B.990(2).

 

      Section 20. Timetables and Standards for Implementation. (1) As a condition for the issuance of a certificate of need, a holder of a certificate of need shall submit progress reports on the Certificate of Need Six (6) Month Progress Report, Form #8, at the six (6) month intervals specified in this section.

      (2) A notice specifying the date each progress report is due shall be sent to every holder of a certificate of need whose project is not fully implemented.

      (3) The cabinet or its designee shall review a progress report and shall determine:

      (a) If the required elements have been completed; and

      (b) If the required elements have not been completed, if sufficient reasons for failure to complete have been provided.

      (4) A certificate of need shall be deemed complete when:

      (a) The project has been approved for licensure or occupancy by the Office of Inspector General; and

      (b) A final cost breakdown has been submitted.

      (5) Until a project is deemed complete by the cabinet, the cabinet may require:

      (a) The submission of additional reports as specified in subsections (16) through (18) of this section; or

      (b) Progress reports in addition to those required at six (6) month intervals under the provisions of this section.

      (6) Except for long-term care bed proposals, a certificate of need shall not be revoked for failure to complete the items required during a six (6) month period, if the holder of the certificate of need establishes that:

      (a) The failure was due to emergency circumstances or other causes that could not reasonably be anticipated and avoided by the holder; or

      (b) Were not the result of action or inaction of the holder.

      (7) If the cabinet determines that required elements have not been completed for reasons other than those set forth in subsection (6) of this section, it shall notify the holder of the certificate of need, in writing, that it has determined to revoke the certificate of need.

      (8) The revocation shall become final thirty (30) days from the date of notice of revocation, unless the holder requests a hearing pursuant to KRS 216B.086.

      (9) The first progress report for all projects other than long-term care beds shall include:

      (a) For projects for the addition of new services or expansion of existing services that do not involve construction, renovation or the installation of equipment: plans for implementation of the project;

      (b) For projects for the purchase of equipment only: a copy of the purchase order;

      (c) For projects involving the acquisition of real property: evidence of an option to acquire the site; or

      (d) For construction or renovation projects: evidence that schematic plans have been submitted to the Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet, Department of Public Protection, Office of Housing, Buildings and Construction, and the Office of Inspector General.

      (10) For projects other than long-term care beds not deemed complete, a second progress report shall include:

      (a) For projects converting beds: documentation that all beds are licensed;

      (b) For projects for addition of new services or expansion of existing services that do not involve construction, renovation, or the installation of equipment: documentation of approval for licensure and occupancy by the Office of Inspector General or the Kentucky Board of Emergency Medical Services; or

      (c) For construction or renovation projects: the schedule for project completion, evidence of preliminary negotiation with a financial agency, and evidence of preliminary negotiation with contractors.

      (11) For projects other than long-term care beds not deemed complete, a third progress report shall include:

      (a) For construction or renovation projects:

      1. Copy of deed or lease of land;

      2. Documentation of final enforceable financing agreement, if applicable;

      3. Documentation that final plans have been submitted to the Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet, Department of Public Protection, Office of Housing, Buildings and Construction, and the Office of Inspector General; and

      4. Enforceable contract with a construction contractor; or

      (b) For projects for purchase of equipment only: evidence of approval for licensure and occupancy by the Office of Inspector General.

      (12) For projects other than long-term care beds not deemed complete, a fourth progress report shall include documentation of final plan approval by the Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet, Department of Public Protection, Office of Housing, Buildings and Construction, and the Office of Inspector General and evidence that construction has begun.

      (13) For projects other than long-term care beds not deemed complete, a fifth progress report shall include documentation that construction or renovation is progressing according to schedule.

      (14) For projects other than long-term care beds not deemed complete, a sixth progress report shall include documentation that the project has been approved for licensure or occupancy by the Office of Inspector General and, if required, that the appropriate license has been approved for the health care service or facility.

      (15) For projects other than long-term care beds not deemed complete after the sixth progress report, the certificate holder shall, upon request, provide the cabinet or its designee with a written statement showing cause why the certificate should not be revoked. The cabinet may defer revocation action upon a showing by the certificate holder that the project shall be completed on a revised schedule. The cabinet or its designee may require additional progress reports.

      (16) For projects involving long-term care beds:

      (a) The first progress report shall include:

      1. A copy of the deed or lease of land for projects requiring acquisition of real property; and

      2. Evidence that final plans have been submitted to the Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet, Department of Public Protection, Office of Housing, Buildings and Construction, and the Office of Inspector General.

      (b) For projects involving long-term care beds not deemed complete, a second progress report shall include:

      1. For conversion of bed projects, documentation that the beds in the project are licensed; or

      2. For construction projects:

      a. Schedule for project completion with projected dates;

      b. Documentation of final financing;

      c. Documentation of final plan approval by the Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet, Department of Public Protection, Office of Housing, Buildings and Construction, and the Office of Inspector General; and

      d. Enforceable construction contract.

      (17) For projects involving long-term care beds not deemed complete, a third progress report shall include documentation that construction or renovation is progressing according to the schedule for project completion.

      (18) For projects involving long-term care beds not deemed complete, a fourth progress report shall include documentation that the project has been appropriately licensed and approved for occupancy by the Office of Inspector General.

      (19) The cabinet or its designee may grant no more than three (3) additional extensions of six (6) months for good cause shown if the certificate holder of long-term care beds has failed to comply with the relevant progress report requirements established in this section.

      (20) If the project involves a capital expenditure, a final cost breakdown shall be included in the final progress report.

      (21) If the Office of Inspector General discovers a violation of terms and conditions listed on a certificate of need and license while it is conducting its annual licensure inspection, it shall refer this violation for a show cause hearing in accordance with Section 18 of this administrative regulation.

 

      Section 21. Biennial Review. (1) Certificate of need holders may be subject to biennial review to determine if they are in compliance with the terms as listed on their certificate of need.

      (2) Biennial review may be conducted within sixty (60) days of the second anniversary of the final progress report and at twenty-four (24) month intervals thereafter.

      (3) The cabinet or its designee shall provide sixty (60) days' advance written notification to the subject of any biennial review, including the following:

      (a) When the biennial review shall be initiated;

      (b) Request for information necessary for the review to which the cabinet does not have ready access; and